James Ye knew that his father-in-law, Christopher, was extremely dissatisfied with Elizabeth Ma. These grievances had accumulated over the years of their married life. Especially after Maria Han returned to the country, Christopher saw how much better Maria was compared to Elizabeth, which only intensified his dissatisfaction. He even thought about divorcing his mother-in-law, Elizabeth, but she refused to give him the opportunity, so now he couldn't see eye to eye with her at all.

However, in James Ye's view, Christopher's little thoughts were somewhat petty. It was just a set of cosmetics, and if he were to get a fake one to fool Elizabeth, it would be quite disgraceful. It wouldn't matter if Elizabeth found out, but if his wife, Mary Xiao, knew he got fake skincare products for her mom, she would certainly be displeased.

So he said to Christopher, "Dad, don't worry about this. Just hurry up and take this set of skincare products to Auntie Han."

Christopher nodded and said, "By the way, James, I won't be home for dinner tonight. There's a gathering at the senior university."